Question for Terry Ryan detractors
I covered the 1998 Winter Meetings, when the Dodgers signed Kevin Brown for $105 million. I’ll never forget that silly look on GM Kevin Malone’s face. Or the look of disbelief and disgust from everyone else at the hotel — except for Brown and Scott Boras.
Maybe it’s from covering the smaller-market Padres and then switching to Malone’s Dodgers, who went on to give Darren Dreifort $55 million. Maybe it’s from arriving in Baltimore for the tail end of the Scott Erickson deal (post-surgery). But I have a tendency to think conservatively when it comes to big, long contracts for pitchers.
Twins Nation is frustrated with Terry Ryan for shelling out $3.1 million for Ramon Ortiz. Disgusted mostly because he and Sidney Ponson ($1 million) have blocked the path of the Rochester Quartet. Before Sunday’s strong outing, Carlos Silva was 0-4 with a 6.17 ERA for May, making it harder to defend picking up his $4.3 million option.
But if the worst of these decisions was Ortiz, I ask you to compare the following five investments and tell me: Which is the best? And, which is the worst?
1) The Twins spending $3.1 million for Ramon Ortiz.
2) The Yankees spending $46 million (including the posting fee) for Kei Igawa.
3) The Yankees spending $39.95 million for Carl Pavano (circa 2004).
4) The Giants spending $126 million for Barry Zito.
5) The Brewers spending $42 million for Jeff Suppan.
You can argue that Suppan’s signing doesn’t look all bad right now, and maybe he was exactly what the 2007 Brewers pitching staff needed. You can argue that it’s way too early to evaluate Zito’s deal. You can argue that the Yankees spending tens of millions for Pavano and Igawa is the same drop in the bucket for them as the Ortiz signing was for the Twins.
But for those who think Ryan has made bad decisions, keep some perspective. If he had signed Suppan, and Suppan had turned into a Pavano-like injury bust, the Twins would be in a terrible financial hole. Not just this year, but for every year until 2010.
For six years, I covered the Dodgers and Orioles, listening to talk about how they couldn’t wait to get out from under “bad contracts.” Look at the Twins: There are almost no bad contracts. Besides losing David Ortiz, Ryan’s biggest all-time regret is the four-year, $20 million deal he gave Joe Mays after Mays won 17 games in 2001.
Right now, the Twins are second-guessing themselves for misjudging Jesse Crain’s durability, when they gave him the three-year, $3.25 million contract this spring. But that’s a far cry from how the Yankees misjudged Pavano’s durability.
This is a tough argument to make right now, but I still believe the one-year deals for Ortiz, Ponson and Silva have served a purpose. All it took was one week watching Twins relievers drop like flies to remind everyone why people always say, “You can never have enough pitching.” Some think Ryan should have bypassed all three of those veterans and gone into spring training with Johan, Boof, Garza, Slowey, Perkins and Baker.
Well, now Perkins is hurt. He is 24. He never had an arm injury. Now he does.
So Johan & The Rising 5 would be down to Johan & The Rising 4. That sounds pretty thin, especially when there are still 113 games left to play.

Mike Redmond’s wife, Michele, and their two sons visited during the last Twins homestand, giving them a chance to celebrate his 36th birthday and Mother’s Day together. Their son Ryan is 6, and Michael is 4. (Photo, right, is from
Stuck at DFW this morning after a certain airline canceled my flight. I’m frustrated … and sad. One of our favorite web sites, 
