Central Intelligence: Pitching breakdown
“Detroit is going to run away with this division now,” I found myself telling people this past week. It was getting impossible to argue with an offense that leads the majors with 460 runs scored, compared to 410 for Cleveland (ranked second in MLB) and 356 for the Twins (ranked 13th). The Tigers also have Kenny Rogers back, adding to their already impressive starting rotation.
But the Tigers placed Fernando Rodney back on the DL yesterday. Closer Todd Jones is 0-3 with a 12.54 ERA since May 28. And who can predict how dominant Joel Zumaya will be when he returns from his ruptured finger tendon? Reading this game story of Detroit’s loss last night gave me the impression the Tigers need to trade for bullpen help, and soon.
“I’ll make this real simple,” Leyland said. “We got outpitched, outmanaged, outplayed and outhit. We lost. Goodnight. See you later.”
Cleveland pulled back into a tie for first with the Tigers last night. It was an impressive win because the Indians scored three runs off Oakland’s Dan Haren, who has not lost since April 7 and because of their five-run, ninth-inning rally. Notice how much Oakland misses closer Huston Street.
Meantime, in Minnesota, the Twins got five hitless innings from their bullpen. Pat Neshek got five outs (including 3 Ks) and made it look easy. Joe Nathan had a 1-2-3 10th and a 1-2-3 11th (also notching 6 Ks). “That’s as good as I’ve seen the ball come out of his hand in a long time,” Manager Ron Gardenhire said.
We’ve spent a lot of time here discussing offense. Last night, Shaun Marcum and a Blue Jays bullpen that ranks third in the majors with a 3.38 ERA pretty much dominated the Twins’ hitters. But here’s a breakdown of how the three top teams in the AL Central compare pitching-wise, this morning:
Team Team ERA (MLB Rank) Starter ERA (Rank) Bullpen ERA (Rank)
Tigers 4.45 (17th) 4.04 (10th) 5.25 (28th)
Indians 4.39 (15th) 4.59 (17th) 3.92 (14th)
Twins 4.16 (11th) 4.48 (16th) 3.52 (6th)
That Detroit bullpen is the reason I won’t be predicting a Tigers runaway now. I don’t know what to make of Cleveland. I haven’t been a believer from the start. But the Twins’ bullpen is the reason I think they can hang in this thing until the end.


First, another tribute to those who make us laugh: Our last trade target was 
