Meet the new starting shortstop for the Twins
Adam Everett is listed on the roster at 6-foot-0, 170 pounds and widely considered among the best defensive shortstops in baseball. But on June 14, he went back for a fly ball, and … “Houston, we have a problem.”
Also chasing that fly ball was Astros left fielder Carlos Lee — all 6-2, 240 pounds of him. They collided (photo courtesy Houston Chronicle). Everett broke his right fibula. The healing process took longer than expected, and he didn’t return until Sept. 20, playing just three games before season’s end.
I spoke to Everett’s agent, Keith Grunewald, and he said Everett is back to 100 percent. In fact, Everett went to Houston on Tuesday to run in front of the Astros’ trainers, and everyone seemed encouraged. But the next day, Houston completed a long-anticipated trade for Baltimore shortstop Miguel Tejada. With no place for Everett, the Astros non-tendered him.
“We saw this trade [for Tejada] coming for two years, I guess,” Grunewald said. “But the Astros have always been very good for Adam. He certainly appreciates his time there. Now he’s looking forward to his time with the Twins. They have a great organization.”
Everett made $2.8 million last season, and the Twins signed him to a one-year, $2.8 million deal with up to $200,000 in incentives. I think it’s a good signing. As Manager Ron Gardenhire said at the winter meetings, there was nothing certain about the infield other than first baseman Justin Morneau.
I think Nick Punto, Alexi Casilla and Brendan Harris could cover the two middle-infield positions, but I imagined the look on Gardenhire’s face this spring with the lingering uncertainty at shortstop, and it wasn’t pretty.
I’ve listened to Gardy talk about the importance of having a shortstop who can “quarterback” the infield, steadying the entire infield defense. Jason Bartlett grew into that role. Everett already has it mastered. As La Velle wrote today, Gary Gaetti, a four-time Gold Glove Award winner himself, rates Everett’s defense with an 8 on a 2-8 scale.
Anytime a player suffers a broken leg, you have to wonder if he’ll be able to regain his range. A baseball exec once told me that few things decline in baseball as quickly as a middle-infielder’s range as he approaches age 30. Everett turns 31 in February. And for all his defensive skills, he also falls into the category of all-glove, no stick.
He is a career .248 hitter, and his OPS-plus, which compares him to the league average and adjusts for his time at hitter-friendly Minute Maid Park, is a lowly 69. Among the most similar hitters through age 30, Baseball Reference lists former Twins second baseman Rob Wilfong.
Aaron Gleeman gave a thorough breakdown of the Everett signing today, using some of the most sophisticated statistics you’ll find, including Revised Zone Rating (not just Zone Rating, Revised Zone Rating) and VORP (value over replacement player). As usual, Gleeman adds meaning to those numbers with his own analysis.
If there’s one player in all of baseball whose glove can balance out the damage done by a .650 OPS it’s Everett. He’s basically the player that the Twins misguidedly thought they had in [Juan] Castro, providing replacement-level offense and legitimately phenomenal defense (as opposed to Castro’s sub-replacement level offense and illegitimately phenomenal defense). Everett might be 15-20 runs worse than [Brendan] Harris and [David] Eckstein offensively, but he makes up for that and then some defensively.
Everett turns 31 years old in February and missed most of 2007 with a fractured fibula suffered while ranging into left field chasing a fly ball, so there’s a chance that his days of providing dominant defense are in the rear-view mirror. However, he was fantastic prior to suffering the injury and even a slight drop-off in his glovework would leave the Twins with a valuable player at a reasonable cost. Their value comes in different packages, but the Twins have more or less replaced Bartlett with an equal player.
Replacing Bartlett with a veteran equal, and filling a major infield hole during a tumultuous offseason seems like a good move to me, especially when the risk is only a one-year, $2.8 million commitment.


