The Morning Challenge
Posted on March 18th, 2008 – 9:25 AMBy May Chen
Our Zoe’s been a challenge recently in the morning. Won’t get dressed, won’t eat breakfast…instead, she drapes herself lazily on the couch or asks to watch tv…all while we’re trying to get her out the door to preschool. So when Tina Feigal, a Twin Cities parenting coach, offered to guest-blog on a topic - any topic - I asked for tips to deal with little dawdlers.
Among the parents I coach, I find that that one near-universal issue arises at some point in the coaching process: How do we take the pain out of the morning routine? Here are some real solutions to this often-frustrating everyday issue.
Set up a family meeting. Using the same approach that you would with a respected adult, ask your child if she will be available at 6 p.m. on Tuesday to discuss an important issue. Hold a family meeting to share your concerns in a non-judgmental way. This gives the child a sense of being respected and also infuses a feeling of importance into a troubling issue. I recommend this approach for any topic that needs discussion in your family life.
Use the family meeting to lay out the issue of morning squabbles as objectively as you can. You might say something like, “I have noticed that we are having trouble getting going without an argument every morning. I know that when this happens, I get upset, and I imagine that you do, too. I would like to see us have a peaceful morning instead.
Use Present Moment Parenting, featuring The Nurtured Heart Approach for morning experience management. Say, “We need rules. What should the rules be, Kids?” Children know what the rules are, and the ones they offer will typically be more stringent than yours. Use the child’s rules religiously whenever practical, as this creates buy-in, which strengthens the likelihood that the rules will be followed.
If a rule is broken, there is an immediate, non-negotiable break. A gentle, unemotional “Broke a rule. Take a break,” is all that is needed. The break should take place in pre-designated break spots around the house (in the room with you, not in another place) and should last 30 seconds. No energy (no talking, no negotiating, no engagement of any sort) should be directed to the child. The break starts when the child is calm. He can make it start, and make it end! He can exert appropriate power!
For steps that are completed with cooperation, use heartfelt appreciation to show that you are noticing and valuing the child’s actions. You might say, “I see that you have your teeth brushed and are headed to get dressed. Thank you so much for following our plan, Kayla. Every time you do this stuff, I feel like you are making this house such a wonderful place to live!” Using the formula “When you … I feel … because …” for this feedback makes remembering what to say much easier.
Set a definite schedule. Do not consider this optional. It is very good modeling for your children. They need to know that there’s enough time to get out the door without being hurried. Add 15 minutes to your routine, so you won’t have to rush. Remember: child speed is much slower than adult speed.
Include any special rituals in the morning routine that the children deem important, and that are acceptable to you, such as: wash your face, get dressed, find the backpack, eat breakfast, brush your teeth, grab your jacket, and go out the door. Rituals provide a sense of continuity and comfort, which is vitally important to raising healthy kids.
You’ll want to rehearse morning on Saturday afternoon, when you are all home. Everyone gets into bed, has the alarm go off, goes to the bathroom, gets dressed, eats breakfast, finds his backpack, grabs his jacket, and goes out the door. This builds a definite map in the child’s brain for what morning is supposed to look like, which gives the child a huge head start on complying when it’s the real thing. Be sure to give heartfelt appreciation for the cooperation during the practice.
Here’s to a much more peaceful morning for everyone!
Tina Feigal is a former school psychologist and parent coach. She offers coaching over the phone to parents all over the U.S. and Canada. Visit www.nurturedheart.com for more information.
Cribsheeters, what do you think?
12 Responses to "The Morning Challenge"
Sounds nice, will it work for 17 month olds? I think this is geared more towards the 4 and up ages. My 2 year old is just beginning to learn what rules are and mornings are tough enough getting both of them ready and out the door without putting them in “take a break” for 30 seconds. We’ve done the routine, the no routine, the getting up earlier, the going to bed earlier and just about everything. Truth is, everyday is going to be different and no matter how hard parents try to keep things the same, there is always going to be one thing differenet every morning that you can’t control or put into the routine. So, we’ve just learned to go with the flow and the bumps and bruises and get out the door at some point. I’m made it clear with my supervisor that if I’m late, I will adjust my schedule to make sure I work my full 8 hours. It’s a nice article but I’m wondering if this person has any children herself? ![]()
She’s a parenting coach, so I’m going to go ahead and assume that she does indeed have children.
Aaaaah! You’re singing my song! Our 4 year old is also a dawdler extraordinaire and I’m beginning to understand that saying she’s both 4 and a dawdler is really redundant. 4=dawdle
Reading this I realize that our morning routine is probably too variable. We can try and standardize it.
However, I do find that on mornings when we have built in adequate time getting her 4 year old legs to finally cross our threshold is still a problem. Can I put a new puppy in the car every morning?
But still, I’m going to try a couple of these tips. Thanks.
I’m glad this is such a universal problem. When this first started happening I was feeling really guilty about going to work because my 4 year old was having fits about leaving the house in the morning, but he dawdles even when we are leaving to do something fun. I think it’s just that age. I’m not sure that a family meeting would work for my son but we try to have a pretty scheduled morning and I make it a point no matter how hard it is to get out of bed to have breakfast together in the morning and spend some time together before the rush of the day begins. If I’m not immediately yelling at him to get dressed and brush his teeth he seems to be more willing to cooperate. Of course this doesn’t always work (kids are unpredictable) but it helps!
Shannon–
Yes, I have also found that my son responds to getting going much faster if when he first wakes up we spend about five minutes “snuggling.” Getting that time in makes the whole morning go smoother!
Tina–
This is so helpful; we do sort of a version of this but your specific tips are really helpful. One question: What is the age that a kid is cognitively able to help make the rules? My son is 3 1/2…in your opinion, is that too young, and the rules should still be set by us? Or what age would you recommend?
Thanks–
Tina listed great solutions and advice for guiding parents to raise healthy kids. I just finished reading “The Pocket Parent Coach”. What a wonderful book! This book has helped my husband and I deal with day to day issues with our children (one with Aspergers). We have referred many times to her book and have taken many of Tina’s suggestions and put them into play in our own home/family life.
Once again, thank you for the helpful advice.
KB-You would be surprised to learn that a lot of ‘experts’ in fields have no experience of dealing with the subjects in their own personal lives…. I know a lot of principals who have never taught in a classroom, a few career coaches who have never worked another in another field other than being a career coach and a couple of sport coaches who have never played the game themselves…..
The article sounds nice but my parenting of 3 children has taught me that every child is different and there are no set solutions to solve everyone’s problems. This advice may work for one family just fine and another family it may back fire on…
Interesting information though.
Hi MicheleK
I sure understand your perspective on “experts.” I do have three sons, whom I consider to be my best teachers. I designed the morning routine from my experience with them, and the experiences I have had over the past 7+ years as a parent coach. And you are so right: children need individual approaches. I work with parents all the time to customize the techniques I teach, so they are effective for older, younger, brighter, more sensitive, and disabled kids.
Thanks for the opportunity to clarify!
Best,
Tina
Hi Katy,
Yes, I think your 3-1/2-year-old son can get the idea about setting rules. Make some suggestions, so he knows what they sound like, and then see if he can think of some. If he does, be sure to use them, and if not, he will soon! Rules need adjusting as the family grows, so there will be plenty of opportunity.
Best to you and your family,
Tina
MicheleK,
Just one more point about getting the children out the door. If you need a break right before you leave, it happens in the car, a fact you can establish in advance, so there are no surprises. Predictability is a very helpful tool in gaining cooperation.
Also, with children as young as yours, breaks should be used sparingly. You are much better off redirecting behavior with the young ones. “Forwarding the action” works great. “As soon as you fill up your tummy, we’re going to take a ride to school! What toys do you think should go in the car today?” Get the child making an appropriate decision and acting on it, and the focus is off resisting.
Best,
Tina
Wow! Thanks for responding Tina, it’s nice to know the ‘real’ backgrounds of people who are giving advice or recommendations. I appreciate you taking the time to follow up.
My oldest son is 12 so we have been through the battle with him his whole life of getting up and getting out the door. This topic is really close to the struggles of potty training too….
Thanks!
No problem, Michele! I love helping parents with their parenting challenges. It’s my passion! Visit
http://www.nurturedheart.com for more information.
Tina


