Last night on American Idol, the singers performed songs from the year they were born. That means the newest song we’ve heard this season is 17 years old. Ack!
I have to say that I think Ryan Seacrest is a great host, but he looked like a ventriloquist’s dummy during that intro.
Ramiele Malubay, 1987: She does “Alone” by Heart. This is a big song, but she does she have the chops? She starts a little shaky on the quiet, low notes. Oh, my. She has shown a big voice in the past, but she can’t handle the rock power ballad. That was horrible–shouting and off-key. Please, bring back Carrie Underwood and her killer version from several seasons ago. And I have to add that I’m getting sick about hearing how the singers are sick. Buck up, people!
Jason Castro, 1987: He does “Fragile” by Sting. The guitar is back, and he looks much more comfortable. This wasn’t a big song, but it suits him well. He has a knack for picking songs that suit his style. The performance is fine, but he’s too low-key to make a strong impression. Just good. Man, is this dude laid back, or what?
Syesha Mercado, 1987: The drama queen does “If I Were Your Woman” by Stephanie Mills (and Gladys Knight before that). I’m not a huge fan, but this was respectable. She sounds shrill when she pushes, but she did a fantastic job on most of the song–very emotional. I don’t agree at all with Paula that she has a chance to win it. I think she has a slim chance of making it past the top 6.
Chikezie, 1985: He does “If Only for One Night” by Luther Vandross/Brenda Russell, a change of pace from the quick-steppers he did during the Beatles weeks. He actually is quite respectable, but he misses on some of the low notes. I like his smoky-tone delivery. He’s certainly feeling it. But it’s nothing special ultimately. I like the big guy, though.
Brooke White, 1983: The ex-nanny does the Police’s “Every Breath You Take.” After a false start, she settles into a Sarah McLachlan vibe. This was shaky. She seems really uncomfortable. Great song, but it doesn’t quite suit her. It needed much more drive to propel the song. I love her plaintive vocals, though.
Michael Johns, 1978: The old man does Queen’s “We Will Rock You.” It’s just shouting and not particularly memorable. Then he makes a jarring transition into “We Are the Champions.” He should have just done the latter. It’s still not great. He can do Queen, as we found out during Hollywood week with “Bohemian Rhapsody,” but he should have picked something different. Overall, one of the stronger performances, according to the judges, but I’m still left wanting.
Carly Smithson, 1983: The singer, who was named after Carly Simon, does Bonnie Tyler’s “Total Eclipse of the Heart.” She’s pushing but she sounds great, not just because it’s faithful to the original but because she really seems to performing for the first time in a long while. Yikes: A bad miscalculation on the final notes. I don’t agree that it wasn’t a good choice for her, as Randy Jackson says. She still shouldn’t be on the show.
David Archuleta, 1990: The little fella does “You’re the Voice.” He’s actually off pitch tonight. I’ve been wanting to hear him do something up-tempo, but this isn’t it. What does it matter? Girl power will see this guy through. But I’m surprised to hear him cite John Farnham as the source, since that version was from 1986, not his birth year of 1990.
Kristy Lee Cook, 1984: The country girl does “God Bless the USA” by Lee Greenwood. We should all stand up and salute; she’s certainly banking on the patriotic support with this one. There are some iffy notes in the middle of it, but she gets the big applause. Stand up, America! She won’t win Idol, but she might have the inside track on the Miss Congeniality award or headlining the county fair.
David Cook, 1982: The big-headed rocker does Michael Jackson’s “Billy Jean” in the bluesy-folk version by Chris Cornell, fudging the birth-year angle again. That aside, this is the showstopper tonight. Wow. This guy could seriously follow in the footsteps of Chris Daughtry.
So, David Cook was the best last night by far. By far! Other strong performances included Carly, Syesha and Michael. Overall, though, it was a lackluster night that was saved by David Cook.
Who’s going? I’d say Chikezie. But who else will be in the bottom three? Ramiele and … ? Kristy seems safe after pandering with the patriotism, but it might keep her safe for another week. What do you think?