StarTribune.com

The bailout baby bust?

Posted on December 12th, 2008 – 4:05 PM
By Kara McGuire

There’s a story circulating out on the web about how more couples are waiting to have kids due to the poor economy.

According to the story:

As the financial crisis reverberates through Wall Street, Washington and beyond, it is taking a personal toll on couples who are making the painful decision to postpone starting — or growing — their families. Once hopeful about their ability to provide for children, prospective parents are now filled with gnawing doubts as jobs vanish, retirement savings dwindle and housing prices fall — even as the cost of having and raising a child rises.

Historically, economic downturns tend to reduce the number of children born in the U.S.  In fact, the story said the post-war fertility rate low of 1.7 was in 1976 — my birth year. Maybe that has something to do with my utter disregard for economic events when it comes to childbearing.

Then again, I became pregnant with my third kid long before the stock market took its nosedive, before the first major bank failure and before the bailout bill. I had figured we were probably in a recession. And it was no secret that my job is insecure given my trade.

Honestly, I doubt the official declaration of a recession, or even a job loss would have changed my mind to have a third kid. I’ve never been one of those “wait to have kids until I’m ready” kind of people.

When does “ready” happen, exactly? A person can lose a job at any time. Financial curve balls can be thrown during the best of times. That’s why you plan and live within your means.

In some ways, I think tough times help to cement what matters most in life. For me, family is part of that equation.

I’m definitely more of an “I want to have kids and it’s not always going to be easy” kind of person. I figure if people could raise kids during the Great Depression, during world wars, in Minnesota without plumbing in the winter, then my kids can probably stand to (gasp!) share a bedroom in a 1500 square foot house in the city.

Given our solidly middle class status (I’m a journalist, my husband works for the state), I can only chuckle at people who say having a third child is a status symbol of the rich. How about of the frugal (or possibly the insane)?

I don’t mean to discount how pricey it can be to raise a child. The figures from the USDA on cost of raising a child are terrifying. The cost of quality child care rivals a mortgage. Diapers are a pretty penny. And if your survival income is unstable because of the economy, it may make sense to wait.

But I also think the baby industry in this country has gotten out of hand and that you can safely equip your household for baby through Craigslist and hand me downs. The list of what you “need” before you give birth is absurd.

My son wore his share of his sister’s clothes during his first couple of years. I detect no damage, although (cue mock horror) he did ask for pink icing on his 3rd birthday cupcakes.

As for saving for retirement and college, sometimes you can’t afford to fund everything to the max.  But I think it’s OK to make those choices. Having a family, like managing your money, is all about juggling, trade-offs, and sacrifice.

8 Responses to "The bailout baby bust?"

mike d says:

December 12th, 2008 at 9:14 pm

Excellent post, Kara, making me feel just a tiny bit better about our decision to adopt our third child and give our two biological children (boys) a sister. Of course, my job is relatively secure, but it’s not like there’s a guarantee in stone either. Anything can happen and you can’t predict the future. What you can do is focus on the things you can control and the things that are important to you.

I think it’s interesting in all of these “dire straits” news articles and whatnot always mention things like “retirement savings dwindle”. OK, folks, those are paper losses - if you’re starting a family, presumably it’s a long time to retirement! Hold on tight and leave it alone! I know it’s tough psychologically, and for some (including me) the Roth might be somewhat of an emergency fund, but still - characterizing those declining account values as “losses” or “dwindled” just adds to the panic.

Just my take. And TMQ’s. :-)

Allison says:

December 14th, 2008 at 12:58 pm

My friend and I were just talking about this last night. We both want to have kids soon, but are worried about the economy.

My husband and I start to adjust our finances over the past 6 months to see if we could be “baby ready” before actually getting pregnant. The results have been wonderful!

We have managed to build our savings by “finding” daycare money (around $600/month) in our current budget and moving it to a high interest savings account.

Yes, it is tough, yes I miss getting my vanilla latte each morning, but in the long run, you do just make it work.

This pre-baby planning has calmed my nerves when it comes to affording a baby…now I just have to convince myself I am ready to stop sleeping in on weekend mornings. :)

' + title + ' - ' + basename(imgurl) + '(' + w + 'x' + h +') says:

December 15th, 2008 at 10:20 am

[…] McGuire of KaChing and KaBlog wrote a great post last Friday The Bailout Baby Bust. She links to an LA Times article about couples holding off on having babies due to the economy. As […]

Chris says:

December 15th, 2008 at 11:11 am

There may be an overall baby downturn but there is an expected jump in births in July/Aug and I wouldn’t be shocked to see another in September thanks to the Obama election/inauguration “festivities”

Sarah says:

December 15th, 2008 at 11:34 am

We’re hoping to have baby #1 soon… the financial impact will be felt, but we’ve waiting 3+ years of marriage to get ourselves in the financial situation where it won’t be as hard.

Right now we can live on my salary if we cut out all savings/ROTH contributions and cutting back on cable. 3 years ago that wouldn’t have been possible. So when that day comes, we will have daycare easily covered. I am nervous about the economy, but our country will recover and we are taking as much financial care as we can. I’m not putting off a child because of the unknown.

Kara McGuire says:

December 15th, 2008 at 2:39 pm

Allison,
Honestly, I miss the sleep more than the extra money!

Allison says:

December 15th, 2008 at 4:15 pm

Thats what everyone tells me!

Naomi says:

December 16th, 2008 at 2:42 pm

My Mom and her friends/acquaintances had one or two big bags of baby/toddler clothes that they just passed from person to person whenever they had a baby…nowadays people think you have to get all new stuff, it is pretty ridiculous. That being said, I don’t want to have a kid until I can afford it either.