Q and A, Part II
Posted on September 22nd, 2008 – 7:32 PMBy La Velle
Sorry for the delay. Spent a chunk of the day at a local hospital, checking on a friend who is seriously ill.
from NEI Gopher:
It looks like Hughes & Valencia are both good 3rd base prospects as hitters - How is their defense? - In the meantime,if need be, Chipper Jones & John Smoltz for a few prospects? Atlanta is now on a budget - Might work for a year or two
Let’s focus on Hughes and Valencia.
Luke Hughes has played second base, third base and outfield in the minors-and is not considered a whiz with the glove. At Class AA New Britain, Hughes had a .888 fielding percentage in limited time third base. But Hughes has power potential and there’s a need for an everyday third baseman at the major league level.
Hughes will play third base during winter ball in Venezuela. His ability to get comfortable at that position will be worth watching.
Valencia has many fans in the organization and may be more of a prototypical third baseman than Hughes. But Valencia has only a half year at Class AA and my not be ready.
I expect both Hughes and Valencia to be in spring training next year. Should be interesting to watch - unless the Twins shock me and deal for a proven third baseman during the offseason.
from Jimmy Jam:
1. What is the deal with Ullger’s 3B coaching ability? I see him out of position a lot of times, and why in the hell did he hold up Delmon Young at 3B on Sunday when Punto had an easy double. We almost ran into a huge gaffe there. I realize it wasn’t the reason we lost, but geez.
2. Are the Twins seriously considering bringing back Punto? I don’t have any ill-will towards him, but Tolbert is his replacement and he doesn’t POP-UP as much and is much cheaper. What’s the scoop?
1. Being a third base coach means you’re going to get criticized. Ullger generally has been conservative. His predecessor was nicknamed, `Non-stop Newmie,’ by a slightly husky local columnist. I can’t remember the situation with Young (inning, score, outs, etc.) but you have to factor in all of that with the runner, the arm on the outfielder and where everyone is located when the ball is fielded. It’s not easy.
2. Haven’t heard anything on Punto. But he’s a valuable player because he can play everywhere and is a very good defensive player. I’d like to see Tolbert and Alexi Casilla up the middle next season, with Punto coming off the bench.
That said, I still feel that there have been way too many anti-Punto posts this year. I feel some people continue to rip him for 2007 when he’s hit markedly better this year. I wish he wouldn’t hit the ball in the air as much as he does, but he’s been better. He won’t be the reason the Twins miss the playoffs - if they miss the playoffs.
from jimmy bee:
Why can’t Pohlad spend money like Wilff does???
And where has that gotten the Vikings? The Twins locked up Justin Morneau, Michael Cuddyer and Joe Nathan since last season. They are willing to spend - they are not going to have the highest paid players in the game - but they just need to spend wisely. Trying to squeeze a year out of Tony Batitsta and Mike Lamb have not worked.
from Jimmy Jam:
LaVelle, here’s another question for you. I was down by Target Park yesterday morning on some business. When I came back to my vehicle it smelled like I was inside of a dumpster. Got into my car and it absolutely stunk. Looked over to see that the garbage incinerator was in use. Gross! The smell was not something I want to take in when going to a ball game in the future. What steps are in place so that the fans don’t have to suffer through a reek-filled 9 inning affair?
I drove around the site last week with the windows down and sunroof open. Even stopped the car at one point, got out and stood for a while. I didn’t smell anything like you described. Did you brush your teeth that morning? Or have chili for lunch?
from Logan:
Also, Boof, does he get one more chance in MN next spring or does he get dealt also?
Last, do the Twins miss Torii’s leadership in the clubhouse this year, specifically this month? I know that is a little controversial, but Gardy repeatedly said Torii was a leader in and out of the clubhouse and I am taking him at his word. Nobody seems to have stepped up to to take that role, Cuddy tries, it just isn’t the same.
Bonser turns 27 next month, so there’s still some upside there. The question is if he will remain a reliever or go back to starting. Just when he looked ready to take off as a reliever he’d have a poor outing.
There’s talent there. He can hump it up to 94 mph as a reliever and has a good curveball. He’s won’t be eligible for arbitration until 2009, so the Twins can hold on to him one more year and see if he figures things out. As for leadership. I sense that Justin Morneau has assumed a bigger role. Michael Cuddyer and Mike Redmond command a lot of respect in the clubhouse, but Morneau has been around since 2003, has a good work ethic and his presence seems to be growing.
Then again, Tom Kelly used to say that leadership is based on the pitcher that day….
from Steve A:
What don’t the Twins like in Brian Buscher, Matt Tolbert, and Matt Macri? We keep hearing them talk about getting a legitimate 3rd basemen, but I don’t see anything wrong with giving these guys a shot, especially Buscher. Is it the fact that they want a Right-handed bat for the line-up? Or just aboutdefense? Thanks La Velle
Macri just showed up on the scene this year - and his numbers at Rochester aren’t exactly eye-popping. Right when Tolbert injured his thumb, Gardy was ready to play him every day and move Brendan Harris to third. That, of course, wound up being delayed. Buscher has had a good year. He’s given them a lift at the plate. He’s got to learn how to hit lefties and improve his throwing, but he’s been functional.
I see Tolbert as starter next season. He’s a high-energy guy who Gardy likes. As for Buscher, I wouldn’t blame the Twins for at least considering a deal for a proven third baseman during the offseason. They have the money and the team will be a legitimate playoff threat.
from Kpuck:
What do the Twins do to get the defense back to where it used to be…10th in the league in defense this year. Lot’s of extra outs. Errors aren’t everything…KC has made 17 less errors than the Twins, yet look at their record. Still, a big concern.
If they follow the La Velle plan and have Casilla and Tolbert up the middle, the defense will be fine. If they don’t deal for a third baseman, they’ll have Buscher and Harris to platoon at third. Harris looks solid at third. Buscher has a couple things to work on, but his bat would offset his defensive issues some. And Punto may be around, and he’s a very good defensive player.
from amtrekman:
Is there any chance that Michael Cuddyer and the team would consider a switch back to third base? Granted, he had his breakout season in right field but perhaps now that he’s a bit more of a veteran he could be moved back. It seemed to work well with Casey Blake and the Indians (and now the Dodgers), a player who went from third to right and back to third to help the team.
The Twins remember the last time Cuddyer played third and don’t want to go there with him. He’s fine in right field with a big arm.
from brett:
I posted this as a response to one of Joe’s game wraps last week, but I’m wondering what you can tell us about Deolis Guerra’s adjustments this year. His K/BB ratio was horrible after being better in the same league last year, and stat heads can’t understand what’s going on unless we know what’s happening in real life. Changing arm angles, working on pick-off moves, working on new pitches, what?
Guerra threw hard, but his fastball was straight. In order to get more movement on his fastball, the Twins have him dropping his arm angle. His velo was down from reports that he hit 95 as an 18-year old.
I even called Jim Rantz, the Twins director of minor leagues, this morning for an update. “His velo, I think will come,” Rantz said. “He’s just 19 years old.”
from Walter Johnson:
Be honest, which Twins players did you hate the most when you were a kid growing up in Chicago?
I had no problems with the Twins. I hated the Royals. Hal McRae, George Brett and Willie Wilson would just kill us. And I enjoyed watching the Cubs flounder.
from Bill Burditzman:
Henry Sanchez is hurt, they shut down Parmelee, can’t think of that other guys name. Who else is being groomed as a power hitter in the organization?
Well, Luke Hughes has shown some pop. Class A Fort Myers catcher Wilson Ramos has massive power but is learning how to harness it. One other player they have high hopes for is E-town outfielder Angel Morales.
from Shaun:
Why does Gardy insist on always managing by numbers? Case in point -once again messing with the bullpen and pulling out Mijares in favor of Gas Can Guerrier who promptly gave the Tribe the lead.
Gardy actually plays hunches - starting Brian Buscher against lefties is one example.
from TK(2):
One (almost rhetorical) question: Why can every, and I mean EVERY team hit home runs when it matters except the Twins? True, we hit them when we’re winning big, or down by a lot, but when the game’s close- say we’re down by 2 with 2 on- we Never get them. Why can 29 out the other 29 teams get home runs in that situation, and we can’t? It’s Very frustrating to me, and it has tobe to many others out there I would think.
Is it our hitting philosophy? Do we tell our players to hit for avg. overpower? I could almost guarantee that you could take the Exact same line-up, put it in a different organization, and the power production would increase by at least 15-25%. Am I asking too much for a team that can hit homers at least on par with the Indians?
I don’t think the Twins preach that approach. They have tried to draft power hitters and many of them have failed. Remember when Cuddy, Matthew LeCroy and Michael Restovich were going to change everything? One of them stuck.
They have drafted Matt Moses, David Winfree and Henry Sanchez in recent years but they don’t look to be major leaguers. BAD DRAFTING!
This year looks bad because Delmon Young never got going and Cuddyer has had hand injuries.
The Twins actually have a power development program in the minors in which they take young slugging prospects and have them do drills to increase backspin on batted balls, which leads to more carry and homers. Morneau still does one of those drills. His homers are down but he still drives the ball.
But I’ll state this again: Offense is not the problem with the 2008 Twins.
from Beisbol-a-Go-Go:
1 - is there any way including fines that the team can use to minimize as close to zero as possible sliding head first? (I’m NOT including pickoff moves, many of those have to be head first). The many hand injuries so far this year may have already had a dampening effect but then there’s always LNP who will do it at any time. It was interesting that D&B said at the time of a Randy Ruiz feet first slide into FIRST! that something happened in his minor league career and he has never gone in head first since, so you can teach even “old dogs” new tricks with enough incentives.
2 - which coach(es) are responsible for sliding techniques? Now I’m talking about sliding hard enough to get there but not overshoot the bag so much that you can’t recover. I’ve watched nearly every Twins game this season and maybe my memory is playing tricks but I can’t remember the last time I saw so many instances of Twins making an out by oversliding and so few opponents caught the same way. Is this aggressive approach that Gardy promotes shooting them in the foot at times?
It is acceptable to dive into first base in order to avoid a collision or a tag. The Twins should use every means necessary to stop players from doing it in other situation. Once you leave your feet, you lose momentum. And fingers seem to get busted when diving into first. But players are going to dive into second and third to try to beat throws. Some players hold their batting gloves in their hands to reduce the chances of fingers getting busted up. And, hey, players are trying to make plays. Sometimes they will overslide bases and get tagged out.
Jerry White teaches sliding technique. And Paul Molitor has a presentation every year on the mental side of running the bases.
from Diggity Daz:
Why does the local media never, EVER, put any fire to Gardy’s feet or ask him the questions they should be asking him?
He never gets any crap for the stuff he pulls–I think the media should be MUCH more critical of him. This shouldn’t be a “Well, we were supposed to be .500, but Gardy managed us to 6 games above” year–it should be a “We had a real shot at the playoffs if we’d have just been able to play .500 baseball through September.”
Yost was fired because he couldn’t keep the fire going. Why isn’t Gardy looked at under the same lens, LEN?
Next year, you’ll have the Yankees, the Red Sox, the Blue Jays, the Angels,the White Sox, the Tigers, and the Indians all with a decent chance to make the playoffs. It’s going to be a little tougher to be in the position the Twins were at the end of August of this year, next year.
For the most part, the right questions are asked. The answers often aren’t acceptable to those who read them. Or other forces drive the stories we are writing that day and affect the questions asked. Or it’s a question that has been asked in the past.
Gardy has a better record and more playoff appearances than Yost. That’s a bad comparison. The Yanks, Mariners, Indians, Tigers and others were supposed to be good this year, and we saw what happened…..
from Mark:
Hey LEN III,
Anyway, it’s this: Everyone loves Joe Mauer. He’s a wonderful hitter and catcher. Great guy, local boy, etc. I don’t want this to sound like I’m ripping him, but it might. If I can get ticked off at guys like Manny and others that fail to hustle to first on ground balls to infielders, then why is Joe special?
Case in point. I was down in KC for the series in August. He hits a routine ground ball to the left side. He’s running half-speed to first. Problem is, the ball was bobbled. He then busts it down the last 45 feet and just gets thrown out by a half a step. If he hustles out of the box, he beats that easily. I watch Morneau and he’s busting it down all the way. Kirby was the same way.
I don’t want to hear the Barry Bonds excuse that they play 162 games and need to “pace” themselves. How many times do you REALLY have to bust it in one game? Maybe twice. So let’s go!
Nobody makes a big deal out of it. But, if it makes the difference in one game… that’s what the season could very well come down to.
Thanks,
Players who are ouchy and dealing with minor injuries usually get leeway on busting it to first base. I’m sure Mauer has been given such leeway. Leg soreness is always an issue with catchers. I wouldn’t get mad at Mark Rosen’s kid if I were you.
75 Responses to "Q and A, Part II"
I like Mark’s question about Mauer not hustling. Weren’t his teammates ripping on him last year for running hard every play and wearing himself out? Just goes to show you, you can’t please everyone.
I like Mark’s question about Mauer not hustling. Weren’t his teammates and others ripping on him last year for running hard every play and wearing himself out? Just goes to show you, you can’t please everyone.
Maybe some of the media does not criticize Mauer or other players. Why bother, the fans can be relentless with nitpicking.
Actually, TK used to say CHEMISTRY depended on that day’s pitcher, not leadership.
I know it’s early but given the fact the Strib (Ruese) is ripping the trade, do you think that Smith’s off field moves rank as dissapointing or do you think that the moves results were dissapointinig. I think I liked or could reason with most of the moves at the time, but most of the talen aquired has not fit the bill as far as expectations go.
Will the trade and moves this year have the Twins gravitate towards a specific strategy? Forget the cheap FA and go with the likes of the Buschers of the world? Trade more pitching to fill other talents needs?
More questions about all the errors:
1) Is it possible to determine at which positions the errors came from?
2) Are there stats showing how many unearned runs a team gives up?
3) How many came from throws as compared to boots?
All of this might help in working to improve defense for 2009
mauer’s a catcher. i wouldn’t mind him walking to first on a grounder to help with his legs. people don’t underestand that about mauer, he catches 9 innings a game for 140+ games this year and is hitting .330. that’s insane. like, one of the best hitting catchers ever insane.
David Winfree was drafted in the 12th or 13th round. He’s just 22 or 23 and just hit 19 runs and drove in 87 runs in AA. Moses and Sanchez were bad picks because they have failed and they were drafted in the 1st round. I think that Winfree was an excellent draft choice just for how far he has made it. He’s also got some potential still.
Love the Q&A, Lavelle. I did, however, disagree with one of your answers. Gardy does not manage on hunches. Maybe once in a blue moon, but that’s it. He is strictly by the book. Strictly by the matchups. Strictly by the numbers. It is his downfall as a manager. His other greatest downfall is his infatuation with the pitch count. It’s sickening.
Hope your friend pulls through, LEN
johnrambo,
I’d say putting Everett in for Kubal last Thursday was a Gardy hunch. I wish he would go with his gut more.
Me too, a prayer for your friend. Hope he’s okay.
I have a question.
With the Tigers probably wanting to dump Magglio’s contract, would the Twins consider trading with the Tigers?
I am sure a lot of fans wouldn’t like trading within the division, but come on, can you image inserting a guy that has a 162 game average of .313 and 115 RBI?
imagine not image
Love the idea behind this blog post, La Velle.
Anyway, got a few questions: Which player(s) do you most want to see the twins trade/release this offseason? And who do you realistically want them to go after this offseason? (Not Manny, or anything like that…)
Good effort by you, La Velle, and the posters.
I liked Diggity Daz’s prognostication about how there are some great teams looming next year. I conclude that the AL Central and the Yankees became significantly weaker this year due to some major injuries.
Cuddy and Neshek were ours. But of course Span replaced Cuddy pretty well. So we’ve been luckier with injuries this year — certainly luckier than last year, and much luckier than other clubs (all-star quality losses of Quentin, Martinez, Wang — for Detroit there was Willis and Rogers and Bonderman as a group of important starting pitchers, for the Yankees the loss of Hughes).
Which leads me to strong disagreement with La Velle’s unacceptable response to Kpuck on the 3B situation.
We need someone who can field at that position. It is one of the three Twins weaknesses. Brian B is an RBI machine who can’t throw or charge a ball. We need to replace his defense without losing offense. And that ain’t coming from anywhere within the Twins organization for 2009
Period.
The other two Twins weaknesses are the BP and the need for more HR power.
The BP could be solved already from within with Mijares and the return of Neshek.
HR output could be solved already from within with the further emergence of the young Young and Mauer, in addition to the return of a part-time Cuddy (at platoon DH). But I doubt it.
Beltre solves two of the three problems. You have to make a human judgment on him. His injury recovery may prevent his strong start in 2009. But he’s tough — like a Morneau — and rarely misses games. He’s a pro and surely will see he has a chance at the big ring. He’ll be fine.
(BTW, I don’t think Perkins or anyone else represent a chink in the starting pitching armor. He’s young, and will be stronger next year, as will Slowey. Blackburn is the 5th starter with Boof in the wings.)
Last March, the conclusion was that Baker was our “Ace”. He was to start the first game of the season.
That didn’t work out. But it works out that he’s scheduled to pitch the two biggest games of the year now — today and the last game of the year.
We’ll see how big his shoulders have become.
Delmon is hitting .301 the last 30 days. M&M are peaking/surging. Casilla looks weaker but is in the top third in the AL the last 30 days in OBP. Gomez has had a hot two weeks. Kubel is hot. Buscher remains above .300. Span does not disappoint. Punto hasn’t slid down. Redmond is coming through. Tolbert too.
My question marks are Harris, Blackburn & Slowey, and the BP.
Like TK always said, it’s all about the pitching.
[…] Twins Insider – […]
i cant believe i watch this crappy team
Thanks for answering 1 of my questions anyway.
I agree that offense has not been the primary concern, but it IS frustrating to see the Twins scrimp, scrap, and scrape for 1 or 2 runs, and then (usually the next half inning) see the other team hit a HR to tie it up. The great thing about home runs is that you don’t have to rely on anyone else to drive in runs. Home run? That’s it. You ARE going to score.
(Unless you miss a base of course).
Hope to see some of the minor leaguers make some power contributions within a few years- as well as DY greatly improve in that area.
Going to a W. Sox game to cheer on my favorite team- and NO, it’s not the White Sox.
**The Twins should have made some kind of trade at the deadline**
Just a note about our power generation:
56 players are tied or have more HR’s than our leader (Morneau- 23)
49 of those have More than Morneau.
Of these 49 players, 25 teams are represented.
Teams with at least 1 player with 23 or more HRs. Numbers in parenthesis- players tied with Morneau at 23.
ATL (1) COL 2 TB
SEA 2 (1) STL 4 CLE
PIT 2 (1) CIN SD
PHI 4 (1) LAA 2 LAD
BAL 3 (2) NYM 3 DET
CHC 3 (1) BOS 2
NYY 3 ARI 2
MIL 4 OAK
HOU 3 FLA 4
CHW 4 TEX
With Min., that’s 26. In otherwords, you could stick Morneau on 4 other teams, besides our own, and have him be leading the club in homers.
WSH, SFG, TOR, and KAN. 3 of 4 are in last place.
Also, other than Raul Ibanez of SEA who has 23, Morneau has the highest AB per HR of the top 56 HR leaders. And that’s our home run leader. 2nd on the team is Kubel with 18 (According to this site). Kubel is 85th overall and actually has a slightly lower AB per HR ratio than Morneau.
Almost done… Mauer/Young are 152nd and 153rd on the list with 9 HR’s. We only have 2 players with over 10 HR’s! I didn’t even fully realize that before doing this.
Source: http://www.hrpace.com/
Ok, I’m done with my home run stats/home run rant. Night.
It screwed up my Teams layout. Hope you can still make sense of it.
Nothing against Reusse but he won’t be the first to say the season is a success because they weren’t expected to do much. They could have been even more special if they had an owner who wasn’t cheap and a competent GM. Since 2001 they have had good teams and nothing was ever done to put them over the top. Terry Ryan and Bill Smith either were told to cover for Pohlad or they simply are not cut out to be GM’s. This season and previous seasons were ruined by bad trades, no free agent help or much needed trade deadline deals. They go to K-Mart when they need to go to the best stores to get top line free agents and trade for top line players. No one in their right mind could say the Santana trade was good. 3-4 players are in the Minors and will never contribute and Gomez should be. He is an undisciplined player who won’t be better than he is. Delmon Young was underachieved while Garza and Bartlett have been keys for the Rays. Our moves were getting Lamb and Hernandez who aren’t around and how can we forget the Huskey’s, Sierra’s, Batista’s, Ramon Ortiz’s, Bergman’s, Ponson’s etc. over the years. This team will never spend to augment this team. The new statdium is built on lies. When will this team ever spend money to get quality people and keep them? Thank-you.
With the Tigers probably wanting to dump Magglio’s contract, would the Twins consider trading with the Tigers?
The thing about a trade is it takes two teams to deal. And Detroit will be looking to send Maggs bat far away from any place it could come back to bite them.
It will be interesting to hear the Yankee excuses for not making the post season.The media I’m sure is waiting to see if the record for the division winning Sox or Twins is worse than the Yankees. They’ll jump on the strength of the East and all that crap.
Delmon for Maggs plus $ ??
doubtful - I agree with T that the Tigers would want to send him farther away.
But I would trade Delmon at this point for something decent. I don’t think his ceiling is as high as hoped (even though he is still developing). Plus he’ll never be a great clubhouse guy (which seems important in Minn).
Trade him this off season while his perceived value is still relatively high. He’s make a good Yankee ![]()
Larry, you are correct on the past acquisitions of late career guys that haven’t panned out.
My guess (and I can tell Len3 is for it in his blogs) is that the Twins will make a strong bid for Beltre this off season. Doesn’t necessarily mean we get him, but this is Billy’s chance to make another bold move in the off season.
I agree, if the Twins could trade either Delmon or Gomez this off season for something that fills the missing void (power bat, 8th inning relief specialist) on this team, I would do it.
I know both are young and developing, but I don’t think the ceiling is that high for them - best to trade one of them now while their perceived value is high…
Can you believe if the Twins were to acquire Betre for 3rd base and BJ Ryan for the 8th inning ( Jays want to dump his salary)? I think we’d be one of the 2 favorites to win the American League next year.
However, my guess is that the Twins would only spring for one of their big contracts - not both…
Gotta dream ~
Trade Delmon for one of them plus cash
i’m not sure trading young or gomez at this point in their careers makes much sense. what they have done at comparable points to 2 of the better twins in pucket and hunter:
young at 22; .289 ave, .333 obp, 9 hr, 65 rbi.
puckett 25; .288 ave, .330 obp, 4 hr, 74 rbi.
hunter 23; .255 ave, .309 obp, 9 hr, 35 rbi.
gomez 22; .256 ave, .290 obp, 7 hr, 56 rbi.
both have at least 3 cheap yrs left and trading them for a 1 yr fix doesn’t seem like a very wise move.
not to say either will be pucket or hunter but if we had given up on those players at the same point in their career what would have been the fallout?
cuddy isn’t tradeable because of his contract so probably kubel, who will start to get expensive, and some excess pitching makes more sense to trade. cuddy can dh with buscher and be the 4th of’r. buscher isn’t a major league 3b but may be a decent lh dh.
ggg use DY as a DH and don’t let him field.
Ordonez is too injury-plagued to trade for. Too risky that he won’t play 100 games.
I agree on Delmon only DH-ing. He’s so stiff in the outfield…he actually runs and moves like an over the hill 36 year old outfielder.
I agree with ggg on the hitting statistics, but Torii and Kirby had great athletic ability in the field at 22 and only got better. Don’t think Delmon fits that mold at all.
Can you imagine him in the outfield at age 30? That will be brutal. Future DH all the way although I’m skeptical he will ever be a consistent 20+ HR, 100 RBI guy.
But that gets back to my original comment…do we want a 22 year old guy with limited overall upside to be our long term DH because he’s inexpensive? Maybe, but if I could get the right missing link to this team by trading Delmon, I would seriously consider it this off season.
We could use T as a LF I hear he has mad volleyball jumping skills and could steal away a few HR’s
I think even Ruiz would be a better righthanded DH than Delmon…and cheap too. Neither should play the field. Delmon is strong, but lacks the bat speed to be a really good power hitter.
Delmon’s favorite hit seems to be the dribbler up the middle. Not indicative of a blossoming power guy. Early on Kirby and Torii at least seemed to drive the ball more to the gaps.
We have to many OF’s and I am not sure who will stay and who will go. What does anyone else think???
“…and BJ Ryan for the 8th inning…”
Don’t need any Ryan with Mijares and Neshek joining the team next year.
“…I agree with ggg on the hitting statistics…”
Me too. Delmon’s worth another look. And he seems to be taking to the clubhouse a little better. I’m sure this year has been a little frustrating for HIM too. He’s still very much at the beginning of his MLB learning curve. And he does have power, but the Twins and him are wisely holding back on pursuing that till he learns how to be a solid .290 hitter. He’s almost there, hitting .301 the last 30 days.
Romer - After this year, I don’t think we can just rely on what was a good bullpen previously. Neshek and Mijares had bad injuries and missed a lot of time. Will people be ssaying late next year that those two ran out of gas because of fewer innings the prior year - like they are about Perkins and Crain this year?
Don’t think we can have enough sure bets in the BP. I’d add a proven veteran if I could and see how it all mixes out next season.
E7 too many OF’s what to do what to do…..
E7, Crain hasn’t run out of gas. He has good FB velocity. Yet I’m thinking he may not be back next year. Location. And doesn’t have good stuff like a great slider anymore — at least that he can control.
Mijares has already proved that he’s recovered. We’ll see about Neshek. Having them will allow Guerrier not to be overused again.
It all depends on Neshek. A Crain for Ryan trade would be good, irrespective of the contract commitment to Ryan.
Lavelle, I hope the twins make it to the show this year. I would rather my Chicago CUBS beating them than Ths White SUX
Lavelle, I hope the Twins make it to the show this year. I would rather my Chicago CUBS beating them than Ths White SUX
Bryan Ostrowski
Douglas TP Chicago
The Dodgers won’t let the Cubs get to the WS this year
jimmy - “too many OF’s what to do what to do…”
Here’s what I would do (of course that’s probably why I’m not the GM): Either make Delmon full-time righthanded DH and part-time 4th outfielder. Or trade him for whatever value he has now. His perceived value is still fairly high - if we could get a proven veteran for him that fills our other gaps right now, I’d do it…
E7 should we keep Cuddy also and what to do with Kubel as well. We can’t get rid of Span he has done remarkably well since being callled up
Patrick Reusse: Regardless of how it ends, ‘08 a success
And jimmy is off and running to the toilet to vomit
Jimmy - I’m betting no one would be interested in Cuddy or Kubel because of average abilities or their contract - or would give us very little in return. Keep Span for sure.
But I think we could get more for either Delmon or Gomez - both cheap and with perceived higher upside at this point. We might miss out if they do develop into a superstar, but I think there are too many gaps in their game honestly. Other teams may take a chance on them and give us a more established veteran to fill a gaping void (power bat, bullpen, maybe 3rd base).
A risk either way, but if I were the GM, I’d consider any options…
Jim, agree with you on Reusse - would be more accurate to say this was a season that “exceeded most people’s expectations” versus a “successful” season if we weren’t to make the playoffs…
Fry Dog I think everyone saw this headline going into the season as one of the last things to be said. It makes me sick like Deja vu to read this headline.
E7 I agree with you the only problem I can forsee is if we traded for a power hitter could we afford him or if he was affordable would he be another washed up veteran like RonDL.
I’m with you - moral victory = vomit
Let’s win the title and hang onto our lunches ~
Fry Dog Yeeeeah were cheap and we almost made it. Whoop deee doooo.
Jim, I think the Twins have sufficient interest in Beltre for the power hitter and 3rd base. They’ll probably wait to get reports on how he recovers from surgery first but I think they will try. The FO seems to like him, but they may not get him either. The team saved a lot on payroll this year…so maybe. ??
Wondering if the Twins sent Seattle a player for Beltre plus cash (or include Everett and salary) if that would help Billy sell it to the Pohlads?
several teams have a big need for pitching, florida, col., padres, seattle, brewers. all have infielders that could fit our needs, and they may be available, uggla, atkins, kouzmanoff, beltre and hardy. it would seem that blackburn or perkins would be required in any deal and possibly more. all have the power we lack and all have some flaws be it salary or fielding ability. we have a stock pile off pitching and imo an everyday player is worth more than any pitcher except a true (affordable) ace.
LENIII,
Can you talk about Humber? I heard somewhere he is out of options, what does that mean for Humber and for the twins for next year?
E7,
Everett is a free agent after this year, so he will not be traded for Beltre. I’d like to see a Cuddyer + Perkins trade for Belter, I think it would help most teams.
re: LaVelles’ comments about Punto being back next year:
that would be a mistake. Tolbert and Harris can do what Punto can do with about a fifth of the salary. The Twins should no sign him and use that money (plus the excess they have this year) to sign or trade for a real shortstop (Furcal, Hardy, ?) Enough with stopgap starters.
GGG uggla & atkins either one I would be more then happy with. The others not so much.
I would like to see Uggla and move Casilla to short. Live with Harris/Buscher at 3B for a year and see if Hughes or Valencia are ready when the new stadium opens. FLA would want a SP for Uggla and a low level prospect I would guess. If it takes Blackburn I am ok with that. Duensing may be ready next year. I would also like to know if Mijares projects long term as a SP or RP. Maybe Seth can help with that part.
Just a point regarding the home run comments:
While everyone agrees that “chicks dig the long ball,” what matters in the end is runs scored, not home runs. While the Twins are next to last in HR, they are 4th in MLB in runs scored, behind only the Rangers, Cubs and Red Sox. They are also 3rd overall in hits and 2nd in triples. If we can get a bit more HR production from Mauer, Young and a healthy Cuddyer, we’ll be fine.
I’m more concerned with our young pitchers wearing down, and the complete lack of a bullpen over the last 2 months.
While everyone agrees that “chicks dig the long ball,” what matters in the end is runs scored, not home runs
I think it is all about wins and losses personally
i think resigning punto would be a joke.
gardy can’t resist overplaying him.
get a solid 2nd baseman and move casilla over to SS. tolbert can be the utility player. at 3 million plus punto is far to o expensive.
punto just sucks. horrible horrible baserunner. awful situational hitter (BAWRISP, bunting, etc.) and is overrated defensively. his rzr puts him in the middle of the pack. thanks len for perpetuating the myth that punto is good defensively. and for his hitting? yeah i’ll be the first to admit he’s been better than i expected this year. he still is a career .250 hitter. is batting .263 for the month of september when it counts.
the guy is junk. let him go.
batting ave doesn’t always tell the entire story. everett has 20 rbi in 127 ab’s, punto 27 rbi in 315 ab’s.
everett hits .235, .381 obp with 2 outs & risp. punto hits .200 with .250 obp.
which would tell you punto gets a lot of meaningless hits and not many meaningful hits.
of course all stats are open to interp.
however, he gets after it and battles his tail off.
LEN3,
one more thing:
Gardy has a better record and more playoff appearances than Yost. That’s a bad comparison.
ok. How about this comparison (same city, same fans, same media):
Gardy:
team made post-season in 4 of his 6 seasons (67%)
post season series won: 1 out of 5 (20%)
team w-l record with him as a manager: 618-509 (.548)
post season titles: 0
Dennis Green:
team made post-season in 8 of his 10 seasons (67%)
post season games won: 4 out of 12 (33%)
team w-l record with him as a head coach: 97-62 (.610)
post season titles: 0
Dennis Green who has arguably led teams to be more successful than Gardy (and in the salary cap era it is harder to do it for a series of years in football than baseball) was ran out of town by fans, media and management, while Gardy has been treated as god’s gift to running teams by the same fans and media.
Absurd? Yes. Fair? Not.
Gardy has to go… the bottom line is no titles and unless the media and the fans increase their expectations of this team (check Reusse’s column where he equates “mediocrity” with “success”), there will be no titles here.
It is that simple
“at 3 million plus punto is far to o expensive”
This sums up my feelings about Punto. I have nothing against the guy as a person or a player, but a team that can’t afford even mid-level free agents shouldn’t be spending 3+ million on a utility man, IMO.
Why no mention of Brian Roberts for 2nd? I’ll float out (again) Marlins’ Kevin Gregg for BP help. I’m real skeptical of relying on Neshek returning 100% healthy from just rest.
GGG - I’ll spare everybody mention of what I think of the mere thought of offering LNP a contract extension! If you don’t know you haven’t been reading my visits to these blogs.
Also, how about Cuddyer in LF and keep Gomez and Span for CF and RF? I don’t mind dangling DY as trade bait. On the other hand if that’s not to be, then how about intensive extra work for DY this offseason and spring training on patience at the plate (I recommend Prof. Mauer be assigned that class) and maybe undoing some of the traditional Twins solution of opposite field hitting to bring back some power.
Cuddyer in LF and keep Gomez and Span for CF and RF? I don’t mind dangling DY as trade bait.
How about not
Young has better numbers than Cuddyer this year, is 7 years younger and makes a 5th of what Cuddyer makes. If someone should be traded, that is Cuddyer.
Thry, don’t know what Cuddyer’s trade value is compared to DY. I floated out that outfield because I also would like to see DY DH if he’s not traded. Someone the other day described it perfectly: DY looks like he’s trying to play defense on ice skates. I know he’s got at least one bum ankle but he’s been a defensive adventure out there even earlier in the season.
Yuck, just visited JC’s pregame blog with starting lineups. LNP had better not pull off any boneheaded moves tonight.
Delmon is playing out of position… it is his first year playing LF, plus he is hurt. I hope than next year he returns to his natural position (RF) with Span at left. Still, bum ankles at all, he runs circles around Kubel on the field…
Agree on both, new position as well as Kubes. I’ve mulled over but have been too lazy to look at the configuration of the ballparks where the Twins play the most to see if Span’s speed and superior defense would be better leveraged in most of those parks in RF or LF. This is totally unscientific but it seems like Span gets more action in RF than DY in LF. I’m skeptical about my own statement because that would imply more hits in Span’s direction.
Except for a very few stadiums, Houston and Boston, LF will have more room. This is the case in the Dome where 81 games will be played. Span is wasted in RF. Put him in LF and Young in RF. Young has a stronger arm as well.
It makes so much sense that Gardy has resisted it this year.
you are actually correct that Span catches more balls than Young… here are the numbers:
Span (RF) 623 Innings 182 PO or .29 PO/Inn
Young (LF) 1261 Innings 269 PO or .21 PO/Inn
for comparison:
Gomez (CF) 1208 Innings 418 PO or .35 PO/Inn
Makes sense that Span catches more balls then DY. He’s got a much larger range. Also probably has something to do with batter tendencies…batters are more likely to pull a ball so that probably means we face more left handed hitters then right handed hitters. Just a hypothesis.
Also, Span in right makes perfect sense at the Metrodome because his lateral speed compensates for his inferior arm. RFs usually need better arms then LFs (further throw to 3B, outfielders never have to throw to 1B), but the opposite is true at the Dome because of the short RF wall.
Keep DY, Span, and Gomez because of their age/cost/potential. We’re a lot better at developing our own talent then assessing other teams talent (see: practically all our free agent signings). Keep Kubel because, sadly, he’s this teams third best hitter. Lose Cuddyer because of his age/cost/production. I don’t get why some people are trying to run Punto out of town while almost no one thinks we should get rid of Cuddyer. Baseball is a game of numbers and statistics, and Cuddyer just isn’t cutting it.
